I am having a weird issue. All of the journals can be accessed without login but recently I created a new journal and I cannot view it unless I login. I checked the site access option and both the options there are unchecked. So I am not really sure what’s the issue.
When you created the journal, did you check off the box that says “Enable the journal to appear publicly on the site”? It is on the Administration → Hosted Journals area. Without checking that box off, users can only view the journal unless they are logged in.