Verify that the reviewer is not on the list of contributors

Describe the problem you would like to solve
When selecting a reviewer, we have noticed that it is possible to assign a reviewer who is currently on the list of contributors (not the account that is submitting the manuscript).

Fortunately, the reviewers let us know, but in highly specialized fields, this could happen again. Therefore, it would be advisable for OJS to check not only whether a similar account exists but also to review the list of contributors when assigning a reviewer, in order to avoid these complications in the future.

Describe the solution you’d like
When selecting a reviewer, also check whether they are participating as a contributor; if so, indicate that they cannot be invited to review.

Who is asking for this feature?
Editors, Reviwers

Additional information
None, but this is a feature that should be implemented as part of a journal’s editorial quality control process and to support its transparency.

Thanks, @dagosalas,

This has kind of been pinpointed here, a while back, but it has not really been addressed:

And, your case is somewhat different because it is a contributor, and not necessarily the corresponding author.

-Roger
PKP Team

That’s right; I think OJS should also validate the entire list of contributors to rule out a case like that.